Pick Your Poison After Dark Edition

Pick Your Poison After Dark Edition is the ultimate "would you rather…?" adult party game designed to reveal just how messed up your friends really are. With 350 outrageous Poison cards and hilarious judge-led gameplay, this game guarantees laughter, shocking revelations and memorable moments at any adult gathering.

How it works

Each round, one player takes on the role of Judge. The Judge combines two Poison cards to create an impossibly difficult "would you rather…?" scenario, then expands on the cards with creative details and twists. Other players anonymously vote on which poison they'd pick, hoping their choice matches the majority. The Judge scores when players disagree; regular players score when they vote with the majority. It's a simple concept with endless hilarity and surprising insights into your friends' twisted minds.

What makes it so funny

With 350 outrageous and absurd Poison cards covering every topic imaginable, every game feels fresh and unpredictable. The anonymous voting mechanic removes social pressure and encourages honest (and hilariously terrible) choices. The Judge's ability to expand on scenarios means no two games play the same way. Perfect for breaking the ice, bonding over shared chaos or simply discovering which of your mates is just as unhinged as you are.

Perfect for adult game nights

Pick Your Poison After Dark Edition has earned rave reviews from players who compare it to Cards Against Humanity meets "Would You Rather" — combining the outrageous content you expect from adult party games with the strategic voting and mind-reading elements of classic party game mechanics. Whether you're hosting a house party, celebrating with friends or looking for an icebreaker that actually works, this game delivers guaranteed laughs and unforgettable conversations.

What's in the box

Everything you need for up to 16 players is included: a gameboard for tracking scores, 350 Poison cards covering outrageous scenarios, Pick and Double Down cards for all 16 players, a score sheet and five house rules to customize your gameplay experience.

Product details

• 350 Poison cards with outrageous "would you rather" scenarios
• Judge-led gameplay with anonymous voting mechanics
• 2-16 players
• Gameboard, score sheet and house rules included
• Ages 17+ only — contains mature language and extreme scenarios
• Publisher: Dyce Games
• Fast-paced gameplay ideal for adult gatherings
• Strategic voting combined with hilarious scenarios
• Expandable gameplay through Judge creativity

• Perfect for parties, game nights, holidays and adult gatherings or ages 17+